Conventional AND Organic: Why We're Growing Potatoes Both Ways

written by

Anonymous

posted on

August 23, 2022

We won’t lie to you. Potatoes are a tricky crop. In order to get a high yield of well developed potatoes, you need fertile, well drained soil with lots of nutrients and minimal weeds. You also need to control the risk of disease.

Beyond yield, if you’re anything like our family, you also want to raise a crop that's nutrient rich and healthy for the people eating it. 

Chemical herbicides, pesticides, and fertilizers can accomplish the first set of goals. But complying with the requirements of organic certification seems better for the second. Farmers all over the country face this difficult decision.  

At Red Hill Harvest, we’ve landed on raising a mixture of organic and non-organic potatoes. That said, the certification status alone doesn’t tell the whole story of our potatoes.

What is an organic potato?

Organic potatoes are grown following a strict set of protocols. To be certified organic, the potatoes must be grown without synthetic fertilizer, chemical weed control, or synthetic pesticides. Additionally, farmers must do crop rotation between potato crops in order to control pathogens that can end up in the soil. 

In order to make sure that the organic potatoes grow properly, farmers use cover crops to prevent weeds and increase nitrogen levels in the soil. They also use natural fertilizers like compost and animal manure. 

At the end of the day, the organic certification is more about what you can’t do (synthetic fertilizer, weed control, and pesticides) than what you can do. Our organic program doesn’t necessarily look the same as any other farmer’s. 

Red Hill Harvest Organic Potatoes

Our organic potato program started three years ago when we purchased a piece of property that had been in the conservation reserve program for 25 years. It was immediately eligible to be certified organic, so we decided to try growing some organic potatoes. We also used some of the land for grazing and liked what we saw from the natural processes. The practices that keep the soil organic are changing it for the better. 

For our family, organic potatoes are less about the official certification than the commitment to natural processes and keeping the soil healthy.

Red Hill Harvest Organic Yellow Potatoes

What is a conventional potato?

A conventional potato is one grown without having to follow the requirements of the organic certification. Farmers can use synthetic fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides on conventional potatoes. 

Even more so than with organic potatoes, there is a wide range of ways that conventional potatoes are grown. Our conventional potato growing practices look nothing like those of the giant farms providing potatoes to the supermarket. 

Red Hill Harvest Conventional Potatoes

We focus on a more natural approach to growing conventional potatoes. It’s better for our soil and our health. We grow cover crops ahead of the potatoes to increase soil health. Then, we use a mixture of animal manure and natural fertilizer for the majority of our soil enhancement program. Only 10-20% of the fertilizer used on our conventional potatoes is synthetic. 

We also seriously limit our use of synthetic herbicides and pesticides. Does it mean that we have a few more weeds poking through? Yes, but it also means that we have less soil disturbance. 

We particularly limit our use of fungicides, which are fine on the plants but run off into the soil and harm healthy fungal matter. Plus, our healthy soil leads to healthy plants that need less fungicide to begin with. 

Overall, we use a quarter of the synthetic fertilizer and less than half the amount of herbicides and pesticides that you would find in a regular conventional system. The herbicides and pesticides that we do use are to treat a few key pain points that impact our yield, namely weed control and certain insect pests that we haven’t been able to manage otherwise. 

Our overarching goal is to center the natural processes on our farm. We use the same soil health strategies for our organic and our conventional potatoes and try to limit synthetic inputs to the minimum necessary for a strong yield.

We follow the model of our grandfather. He had to haul synthetic fertilizer thirteen miles with a team of mules in order to use it, so he didn’t use much. He saw a benefit to using a bit of synthetic fertilizer in key places, but the vast majority of his system was reliant on natural processes. We are trying to do the same.  

Red Hill Harvest Conventional Yellow Potatoes

Why grow both conventional and organic potatoes?

Growing both kinds of potatoes certainly isn’t the easiest path. We could get a much higher yield if we were entirely farming conventional potatoes. And we could get higher profits per potato if we were farming entirely organic. 

However, our mission is about feeding our community, not just getting the highest yield or the highest profits. We know that some people will only purchase organic potatoes, but that others can’t afford the higher prices.

We also know that our conventional potatoes are much higher in health and quality than what you find in the grocery store, which is why it’s important that we make them available. 

Now that you know exactly how your potatoes are grown, you can choose for yourself which variety to purchase. Besides, no matter what you choose, any Red Hill Harvest potato will be a step above the rest. 

Purchase the best potatoes today. 


P.s. If you want to learn more about how we grow potatoes click the link below and see how we cut seed potatoes in the spring!


Watch: Cutting 2022's seed potatoes


More from the blog

PCOS Medication for Chickens?

While scrolling through one of my subscribed bi-weekly AG E-Newsletters, a headline caught my eye - “Chicken or the egg (or the drug)?  - Research shows that a common diabetes medication for humans (metformin) can help broiler breeder hens produce more eggs.” I was sitting across from my brother John, and words came out of my mouth that resembled something like, “What in the world are they giving to our chickens now?!?”  As he is subscribed to the same newsletter and is a little more organized than I am, he already read the article; he just smirked. Once I finished reading the article, we discussed whether we thought this was a good idea or not; you can probably guess our opinions. In summary, the article says researchers at Penn State have discovered that metformin, a medication commonly used to treat type 2 diabetes and polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) in humans, can significantly enhance egg production in broiler breeder hens. In a 40-week study, hens administered a small daily dose of metformin laid more fertile eggs, showed reduced body fat, and showed healthier reproductive hormone levels than untreated hens.  The study revealed that metformin influences liver gene activity, increasing the production of yolk proteins and stabilizing blood sugar levels while decreasing genes associated with fat accumulation. These effects mirror metformin's action in humans, where it improves insulin sensitivity and hormonal balance. Penn State This research suggests that metformin could be a tool in poultry farming, potentially extending the productive laying period of hens, reducing flock turnover, and enhancing overall farm efficiency. Significantly, metformin is rapidly metabolized in hens, thus they claim, minimizing any risk to the food supply. (Here’s a link to the full article) If you read the article closely, you can see that this medication is NOT being used and has yet to enter our food system. However, it is a good example of how the American ag industry can create its own problem and solve it by throwing a drug or chemical at it. Let me put this in simpler terms and use the example of Metformin in chicken production. How Big Ag Views the Dilemma Problem: Broiler Chickens do not lay enough eggs, and we can make more money if they lay longer and more fertile eggs. (It will take fewer momma chickens) Solution: Give chickens drugs that affect their hormones, enhancing their egg-laying abilities. Here’s How We View the Dilemma Problem: Broiler Chickens do not lay enough eggs, and we can make more money if they lay longer and more fertile eggs. Solution: Don’t grow chickens unnaturally fast! The issue is that we’ve bred our livestock and crops to grow so fast and so large for the sake of “efficiency” that we’ve become too reliant on drugs and chemicals to keep up with this fast-paced farming method.  Chickens, for instance, used to take 16-20 weeks to reach their market weight; now, they are bred to reach market weight in about 6 weeks! This rapid development causes the chickens to grow unnaturally fast, which has significant side effects for both the chicken and the person.  Things have developed too far for the case of efficiency in our food system.  Statements like this tend to give rise to many arguments, mainly along the lines of There are not enough farmers to produce all of the food.It’s not good for the animals to be out in the open without antibiotics.We can’t grow enough food to feed the world. 1) There are not enough farmers to produce all of the food -  Let’s start by looking at the farmers. In 1776, 90-95% of Americans were farmers. They grew all of the food they needed to survive. Most people had their own garden or small livestock herd. Now, around 1.3% of the population in America are farmers, with the number declining every day. So, how did we get here? Once cities and populations began to grow, it became increasingly desirable for people to hone in on one skill and trade it with others to make the community thrive. (For example, blacksmith, cobbler, preacher, builder, farmer) Most people traded their services and goods within 10 miles of where they lived. This built strong community ties and a willingness to work together.  Eventually, the Industrial Revolution came along and built faster transport, better equipment, and communication. Businesses could trade their goods over a farther distance. This new ability to market to larger numbers of people started the corporatization of the American Farm.  Farming became more efficient after World War 2 with the use of chemicals, tractors, and bigger equipment, which meant that those who were the best marketers, and could sell the most, had the most money to buy new farms and plant more crops. They could afford to buy up bigger and better equipment and land, and in turn, could grow more food cheaply. This caused prices to drop, and the little farmers could not keep up. If we exclude the less than 10-acre farms (which are still vital but don’t make up for a large portion of food eaten in America), we can see that in 1920 the average farm size was 148 acres, whereas in 2022 the average size was 1500 acres! A 1000% increase in size!  This shows the devastating number of farms and farming families forced to shut down their tractors to make room for these big farms. To grow food in a more natural way, we would need more farmers, each with a common goal to feed the world with good food. 2) It’s not good for the animals to be out in the open without antibiotics We will not spend much time on the next argument, which is that it’s inhumane for animals to be raised without the use of antibiotics and drugs. I somewhat agree with this argument. Let me explain. It would be inhumane for us to raise animals in a confinement system without the use of these drugs. All of the animals would be sick and more than likely die, simply because they were not designed to be grown in this manner. At Red Hill Harvest, we believe that God designed animals to be raised outdoors without antibiotics or drugs. When raised in the pasture, there is a much lower risk of getting and sharing diseases because they are never over their manure for more than one day and do not breathe and share the same air. In the case of a confined animal operation, it might actually be more ethical to have lab-grown meat. I don’t see much difference between raising chickens in a barn, where they are kept in a very crowded environment and only fed a specific ration of feed (not free choice), and in a “lab” where the meat is being manufactured. 3) We can’t grow enough food to feed the world. The final argument that we will not be able to grow enough food is simply untrue. Many farms, especially where we live, simply are not suited to have crops grown on them. Rather than increasing a subpar crop of corn and soybeans, we could grow a bountiful crop of grass and other high-quality forages and walk the animals to the feed. (You would also eliminate the need for heavy machinery and help the environment tremendously.) How much sense does it make for us to grow feed, harvest it, truck it, store it, re-truck it, grind it, haul it back to the farm, and finally feed it to an animal?  We recently bought a piece of land that was about 60 acres in total. On the sale bill, it said 40 acres were tillable and around 20 acres were wooded. Really, there are about 5 acres that we consider “tillable” that would produce a decent crop. Rather than trying to grow a grain crop, we let it grow and turn into grass. Then our cows can walk across the steep hills and valleys without causing harm to our machinery or the land. This way, we can utilize all 60 acres (yes, we even let the cows graze the woods when it gets hot) and still produce tons of feed! Way more than we could ever grow if we were to try to plant row crops. It all comes down to the fact that there are no longer enough farmers. Feeding the animals right off the land requires more management and labor to set up fences and work with the animals. With the current number of farmers in America, it would be challenging to scale back to a manageable size. How can we solve the problems in our food system? I believe it would be very difficult to emerge from the hole we have dug as a society. Farms are controlled by so few people that it would be hard to attract new farmers and start more farms. It would mean promoting and helping new farmers buy land, meaning the large corporations would have to dissolve. I don’t know what you think, but I don’t see that happening without significantly disrupting our food system.  You CAN make a difference, however. You can control how your food is produced by choosing where you source your food. A growing number of people are fed up with the current food system and how things are being raised. Things will change if we all join together and make smart decisions in choosing where we source our food. While there are many promising things happening at the government level to promote healthy and sustainable farming practices, it’s not enough.  If we reject food from the corporate world, and support small farms and farmers who raise their products the way you want them to, we can make a change.  I hope that the last paragraph encouraged you to start making a difference. Money controls politicians and businessmen alike, and where you choose to spend it will shape the course of our future.  With the developments of social media and websites, you can see exactly how your food is produced without even setting foot on a farm! You can reconnect with your farmer, reject the highly industrialized, unethical farming method, and support a farm that wants to support your health!

Tariffs: How they will affect meat prices, our farm, and how you can protect yourself from higher prices!

Lately, we’ve had folks asking how tariffs might affect meat prices and what that means for our farm. The short answer? Tariffs could raise costs across the board—from feed and fertilizer to equipment and meat itself, especially in large-scale, conventional agriculture. But at Red Hill Harvest, we’re not tied to global markets the way big ag is. We’re working toward becoming 100% self-sufficient, relying on natural systems instead of imported inputs. That means healthier soil, healthier animals, and more price stability for you. We also sell directly to you, our customer—not through middlemen or commodity markets—so we can set prices based on what it actually costs to raise good food. That transparency and relationship is what helps us weather uncertainty and protect you from price swings. So what can you do? Get closer to your food. Support local farms. Ask questions. Visit. Build relationships. When you choose to buy from people who care, you’re investing in a better, more secure food system for all of us.